Why some fighters prefer defense and others counterattack or attack, and how to fit instruction and training to various personality types
This self-defense tip deals with individualization of instruction. A competent instructor, preferable with university-level training in physical education and sports training, will make exercises “flow” during workouts, will know which games and drills are age-appropriate for the group, how to individualize loads for individual members of a group during the workout, and how to vary instruction to match personality traits of individuals in the group.
Introverts prefer defense — they let their opponents have the initiative and are content to react. If their perception and analysis of the situation are accurate, they can very economically and efficiently dispatch their opponents.
Successful defensive fighters are intelligent (they quickly analyze all information on the situation), calm, adjustable, cold, and calculating.
Example of defensive fighting*: Staying just out of range, frustrating the opponent’s attacks, until the opponent gets tired, upset, and careless. When the opponent is worn out, open to attack, and unable to counter effectively, the defensive fighter safely attacks.
Extroverts prefer attack — they seize the initiative and force their opponents to react. They are confident and optimistic — they are unfazed by their unsuccessful attacks and keep on attacking. Extroverts can also counterattack effectively but do not feel good about fighting defensively — they do not like to wait and leave initiative to the opponent.
Neurotics also attack but they do so out of desperation, do not analyze situations, and act chaotically. They attack, but they are not in control of their actions. Except for the instances when they attack or defend chaotically, they avoid contact with opponents by extending distance.
Successful attacking fighters are persevering, decisive, and obstinate; they like to take risks and to experiment.
Example of attack fighting: Launching a continuous series of attacks to force an opening in the opponent’s defense.
Successful counterattacking fighters are confident, intelligent (they quickly analyze the situation and accurately anticipate an opponent’s actions), dominating (not submitting to the other’s initiative), calm, patient, and independent (not concerned with others’ opinion, doing what is necessary to win without trying to impress anyone).
Example of counterattack fighting: Intercepting an opponent’s attacks by evading, deflecting, or blocking and immediately attacking the openings that present themselves. Some counterfighters deliberately open themselves to an expected attack because they have a counter for it ready. Another way of setting up a counterattack is to attack to elicit an expected defense or a counter from the opponent and then to counter that defense or counter.
Understanding why some individuals prefer defense and others counterattack or attack helps to fit instruction and training to personality. Different remedies are needed for improving the tactics of a neurotic, who attacks desperately, than of an extrovert, who attacks confidently. Instruction should accentuate the strengths and preferences of fighters and on the basis of these eventually diversify their styles of fighting. Instructors who impose one style of fighting on fighters with different characteristics, and have them do the same tactical drills, should be avoided.
Self-defense tip from Thomas Kurz, co-author of Basic Instincts of Self-Defense and author of Science of Sports Training, Stretching Scientifically, and Flexibility Express.
Self-Defense Moves
To learn how your natural reactions can instantly defeat any unarmed attack, see the video Basic Instincts of Self-Defense.
Defend Against Weapons
To learn how the typical street weapons (club, knife, razor) are used by an experienced streetfighter and how to practice with them, see the video Self-Defense: Tools of Attack — Club, Hatchet, Blackjack, Knife, Straight Razor.
Mental Toughness
To learn mental techniques that let you calmly face any threat and act rationally in the heat of a fight, click here.
For a complete list of our products, click here.
